Turn Silver Into Cash

Sell Your Silver With Confidence

From bullion, coins, silver flatware, and jewelry and everything inbetween, bring your silver to Hoosier Coin and Currency for an offer informed by its metal content and potential collectible value.

Get a Silver Offer

What Kinds of Silver Can You Sell?

Silver Bullion

Sell silver rounds and other bullion pieces, with offers informed by weight, purity, and the current silver market.

Silver Coins

Bring in silver dollars, pre-1965 U.S. coins, and other silver coins for an evaluation of their metal and collectible value.

Silver Bars

From small bars to larger investment pieces, we assess silver bars by their marked purity, weight, and market value.

Sterling Silver and Silverware

Sell sterling jewelry, serving pieces, and silverware; we consider hallmarks, silver content, and any collectible appeal.

Silver Jewelry

Turn your old, tarnished, broken silver into cash today. With Silver being at historic highs, it adds up fast. non invasively tested and weighted right in front of you. Never is your items out of your sight during the process!

Silver Plate

Sell Silver Plate. One of Indiana's few buyers of silver plate, this is purely based on weight.

What Determines Your Silver’s Value?

Purity and Weight

The amount of silver in an item matters. We look at its weight and purity, including marks such as .999 fine or sterling .925.

Current Silver Prices

Silver prices change with the market, so the price at the time of your evaluation helps shape an offer for your items.

Condition and Collectibility

A coin’s rarity, demand, and condition—or the craftsmanship of a sterling piece—may add value beyond its silver content.

How Selling Your Silver Works

Schedule an appointment today!

Step 1

1. Bring in your silver coins, bars, rounds, or jewelry. No need to sort everything first—we can review your items together.

Step 2

2. We examine each piece, explain what affects its value, and make an offer based on its silver content, condition, and current market prices.

Step 3

3. Review the offer and decide whether to sell. There’s no obligation, and you’re welcome to ask questions before making a choice.

A Local Approach to Buying Silver

Hoosier Coin and Currency serves Indianapolis customers who want a clear, comfortable way to sell silver. Our work is rooted in the local coin and precious-metals market, where careful evaluation and straightforward conversations matter. Whether you bring in a single silver dollar or a collection gathered over many years, we take the time to look at what you have and explain what we find.

Our mission is to help you make an informed decision without pressure. We consider the details that can affect an item’s value, from silver content and weight to condition and collector interest, then walk you through our offer. As a local buyer and seller of gold, silver, and coins, we aim to make every visit useful, respectful, and easy to understand.

Frequently Asked Questions About Selling Silver

Find answers to common questions before bringing your silver to Hoosier Coin and Currency.

What kinds of silver do you buy?

We evaluate many types of silver, including coins, bullion bars, rounds, and jewelry. Bring in what you have, and we’ll help identify which pieces we can make an offer on.

Do I need an appointment to sell silver?

Contact us before your visit to confirm current hours and whether an appointment is needed, especially if you have a large collection.

How do you determine an offer for my silver?

We consider silver content, weight, condition, current market prices, and any collector value an item may have. We’ll explain the factors behind your offer so you can decide what’s right for you.

Do I have to sell everything I bring in?

No. You can choose which items, if any, you’d like to sell after reviewing our offer. There’s no obligation to sell your entire collection.

Should I clean my silver before bringing it in?

No. Cleaning can damage the surface of collectible coins and reduce their value. Bring your items as they are, and we’ll assess them in their current condition.